Compatibility Analysis
Scar and Alphonse Elric might be attracted to each other precisely because of their opposite personalities. The ISTP and INFP combination has the potential for unexpected chemistry.
Scar
Virtuoso
Scar, a character from Fullmetal Alchemist, shows that his actions and inner self are typical of the ISTP (Virtuoso) MBTI type. ISTPs are “calm observers” and are good at practical problem-solving, which is logical and immediately put into action. Scar’s actions, especially his precise planning and execution when targeting State Alchemists as an avenger of the Ishvalan people, are a manifestation of his analytical approach that uses Introverted Thinking (Ti) as his main function rather than Extraverted Thinking (Te), and his sharp adaptability to the environment through Extraverted Sensing (Se). He does not talk much and rarely shows his emotions, so he is often seen as a solitary and dangerous person by those around him, but this is due to the ISTP’s nature of valuing introspection and independence. In the early part of the story, he is driven by his personal mission of revenge against the state and is in a hostile relationship with the Elric brothers, but as he learns the truth, he shifts to a cooperative relationship under the common logical goal of “achieving the objective.” This shows that ISTPs prioritize the situation at hand and logical judgment over emotional ties. The transmutation circle on his right arm is a symbol of how he has sublimated his past trauma into a physical skill, and it embodies the ISTP’s “talent for handling tools” and “commitment to technology.” Scar’s charm lies in the deep conviction hidden in his taciturnity, his rare combat skills, and his human conflict in trying to break the chain of revenge in the end, and he has established a firm position as one of the most complex and fascinating anti-heroes in the world of the work.
Alphonse Elric
Mediator
Alphonse Elric of Fullmetal Alchemist, contrary to his huge armor, embodies the kindness and idealism of a typical INFP (Mediator). The core of the INFP, Introverted Feeling (Fi), is expressed in his deep empathy, especially his love for small animals including cats, and it supports his behavior pattern of not losing his humanity or kindness even in the harsh fate of his soul being fixed to the armor. In contrast to his brother Edward Elric, he is always a calm and peace-loving being and plays the role of an ethical compass in the world of the work. In contrast to Ed’s impulsive and straightforward personality (often seen as ENTJ or ESTP), Alphonse is in the position of a “conscience” who is thoughtful and stops to consider the feelings of others. The relationship between the brothers is based on Alphonse’s INFP-like receptiveness and deep trust in Ed, and it is the driving force behind their goal of “regaining their original bodies,” which is the motivation for their journey. His charm lies in the gap between his physical greatness and the purity of his soul, and his strong inner values, unique to INFPs, and his unwavering determination to protect them capture the hearts of many readers. He is a rare character who quietly appeals for the importance of holding on to ideals and kindness even in the midst of harsh reality.
Tips for Better Relationship
- • It's important to try to understand each other's way of thinking
- • Accept differences as diversity rather than rejecting them
- • Finding common ground will help close the distance
About Scar and Alphonse Elric's Compatibility
We analyzed the compatibility between Scar (ISTP) and Alphonse Elric (INFP) from 鋼の錬金術師 using MBTI personality theory.
ISTP (Virtuoso) is characterized by unique traits. Meanwhile, INFP (Mediator) is characterized by unique traits.
Their compatibility score is 40%, rated as Rank D. This can be described as compatibility with growth potential.